The impact of Manchester Building Society
For practitioners handling professional negligence claims, establishing the scope of a defendant’s duty remains central to determining whether a claimant’s losses are recoverable. The Supreme Court’s decision in Manchester Building Society v Grant Thornton UK LLP [2021] UKSC 20 continues to provide important guidance on this issue.
The case arose from negligent advice given by Grant Thornton concerning the accounting treatment of interest-rate swaps. Relying on that advice, Manchester Building Society entered into a number of transactions and subsequently suffered substantial losses when the accounting treatment was found to be incorrect. The Supreme Court held that the losses fell within the scope of Grant Thornton’s duty of care, although damages were reduced by 50% to reflect the Society’s contributory negligence.
The significance of the decision for professional negligence lawyers extends beyond its particular facts. The Supreme Court clarified the approach to the SAAMCO principle, rejecting an overly rigid distinction between cases involving “advice” and those involving “information”. Instead, the scope of a professional’s duty should be determined by considering the purpose of the engagement and the risk the duty was intended to guard against.
For practitioners, this places considerable emphasis on analysing the retainer, the purpose for which advice was provided and the precise nature of the risk that materialised. It also demonstrates the importance of distinguishing between questions of duty, causation and contributory negligence when assessing a claim and quantifying recoverable loss.
These are just some of the issues we’ll be discussing at the CLA Autumn Conference, taking place in London on 23 September. With expert speakers and a programme focused on the issues that matter to professional negligence practitioners, it promises to be an excellent opportunity to keep up to date with developments in this evolving area. Book now to take advantage of early booking discounts.